Context
I like my way to interpret this album, so I’m completely against researching it. The beauty of David Bowie’s Blackstar is its legacy; the death of a music legend. In a way just like Heath Ledger’s role as The Joker. All you need to know is that this album has “death” all over it, and oh boy it shows.
I still have to listen to much of Bowie’s discography, so I’m no expert. However you can always expect the following of a Bowie album: It’s probably good. Yeah, I’m a fanboy.
So to homage Bowie, today being the day he died back in 2016, here’s my Album Review for his last album.
Rating Theme: Dollar Days
Blackstar: Intro Song
We start off with the title track and probably the most “WTF” song of the bunch; specially if you watch the music video. I could talk for days and days about “Blackstar”, but how does it rank as an Intro? First of all, it sets the mood perfectly, even though it’s the weirdest and no song reaches its level of crazy in the album. It’s also an extravagant track, with many stuff going on and it lasts for about 10 minutes. So it’s clearly an above average intro. But is it a great one? Does it deserve a 5/5? Man, I think it’s not only a 5/5 Intro Song but it could also be a 5/5 Closing Song. “Blackstar” is weird, but it has a perfect structure, atmosphere and theatricality.
When I listen to “Blackstar” I feel like I’m listening to death and rebirth at the same time. A great achievement.
Grade: 5/5 Dollars
Blackstar: Variation Of Songs
So this album is pretty quick, kinda. It has 41 minutes, but only seven tracks. As stated before the title track has a lot of stuff going on for it. It’s weird space horror, jazzy slick and beautiful melodic all over its run time. There’s a bunch of sounds and instruments, like horns and all that good stuff.
After that we go to “‘Tis a Pity She Was a Whore”, a more straight forward song, that still manages to maintain the mindfuckery of what was established with the opener. This one has some fast, energetic drums that does help break the pacing so far, but still feels like the same album, with weird sounds and horns.
“Lazarus” is “chill and kill”; a term I just created. Like, it flows really smooth, cause of that sweet melodic arrangement, but it still manages to be super moody and eerie. Some might feel kinda uncomfortable; again, specially with the music video.
“Sue (Or In a Season of Crime)” yet again keeps the weird going, and it is all over the place. Very noisy and shit. It’s in the same spirit as the second track, with fast, energetic drums, but way less melodic. Bowie talks trough it, basically.
As we arrive at “Girl Loves Me” we realize the weird shit just got groovy. It’s exactly what you would imagine if you wondered: “Is there a groovy Bowie version of this weird shit I’m listening?” And well, the title track had that in some parts, but “Girl Loves Me” is that from beginning to end. The backing vocals might be too moody for some people though. (I hope some one finds Monday one day.)
“Dollar Days” is feel good track, with a slight touch of “last day of vacation”, in which you’re happy, but sad. It’s not weird like those that came before, so as close as possible to a radio friendly track. It really has some stand out horns in it. Very melodic.
“I Can’t Give Everything Away” is almost like it comes from another album. But those eerie drums and orchestral you’ve been listening still creep their way in. So it’s in a nutshell: The happy version of a “Blackstar” album track. This one could be easily played in the radio without making you wonder about life and death.
That’s all the seven tracks. They sound similar overall, except for the title track (a truly special one) and maybe an argument can be made regarding “Lazarus”. However the album does have variation: some happier parts, groovy instrumental and orchestra. But honestly, the title track has more variation in itself than the rest of the album.
Grade: 4.1/5 Dollars
If the album felt a little more balanced, it could’ve been a 5. But it sounds way too moody overall.
Blackstar: Closing Song
“I Can’t Give Everything Away” does not feel like a finale. That’s my biggest disappointment with this album. Such brilliant beginning, but a standard melodic friendly track to end it. Don’t get me wrong, I’m not saying it’s a bad song, I’m claiming it doesn’t fulfill the role of ending the album well enough.
Grade: 3/5 Dollars
Blackstar: Hits & Deep Tracks
Album is not old enough = Hard to say. So we would have to go to my opinion. So this is how I’m gonna do it from now on regarding albums that are recent: “From what I see” (Based on facts) and “Theory From 10 years from now” (My opinion)
From What I See
Hits: “Blackstar” and “Lazarus”. They are present on the only Bowie Hits album released after “Blackstar”, the album. So that’s pretty much it, ma rite? Is there’s another Greatest Hits album I should know of, tell me.
Grade: 3/5 Dollars
10 Years From Now
I believe both of these songs will still likely be considered the hits from this album. The rest is great, but not as unique as “Blackstar” and “Lazarus”. Maybe a third song can be added, like “I Can’t Give Everything Away”, since it’s the most radio-friendly one. So 3 songs.
Grade: 3.5/5 Dollars
Blackstar: Album Order
It’s fine. When I listen to it I don’t feel like something is out of place. However, it’s not great, I believe. This album doesn’t exactly makes you feel a “Middle” and “End”. As for “Beginning” it works really well with the combo “Blackstar”, “‘Tis a Pity She Was a Whore” and “Lazarus”. Of course this part is the most subjective of all my categories.
Grade: 2.8/5 Dollars
*Blackstar: 3.6/5
*Blackstar: 3.7/5
“Blackstar” is not a top-shelf David Bowie album for me. However is undoubtedly gonna become his most legendary. I personally love all the albums I heard of Bowie, but this one was “The Death Album”, this one is the last one, it’s very symbolic and final. “Blackstar” = Heath Ledger’s Joker performance.
The “*” refers to 10 Years From Now
The “*” refers to From What I See